A U.S. judge acquitted two MIT brothers in a $25 million MEV case
On November 16, U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in the Southern District of New York ruled that Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno did not constitute telecommunications fraud, conspiracy to commit telecommunications fraud, or conspiracy to commit money laundering, and the case was subsequently closed. The two were accused of profiting approximately $25 million in 2023 by exploiting Ethereum's transaction ordering mechanism; this case is the first criminal case in the U.S. targeting maximum extractable value (MEV) operations. The jury had previously failed to reach a consensus in 2025, leading the court to declare a mistrial.
Prosecutors alleged that the brothers attracted sandwich bots through eight bait transactions and then adjusted the transaction order using relay software vulnerabilities, causing the bots to lose approximately $25 million. The judge found that telecommunications fraud must involve significant false statements, and bait transactions did not constitute a commitment; the relay also did not verify the forged fields, which did not affect the behavior of the receiving party. In her ruling, Clarke stated that Ethereum is an "environment that is trustless, highly adversarial, and has no terms of use."